Neubauer-Muesing won six NCAA Division III titles between cross country and indoor and outdoor track & field, and earned seven All-America honors — including a Division I award for cross country in 1983. She is one of just four women in Division III cross country history to win multiple individual titles, doing so in 1982 and 1983. During her outdoor track career she claimed 3000m and 5000m NCAA Division III titles in 1983 and 5000m and 10,000m titles in 1984. To this day she still holds the outdoor UW-La Crosse records at 3000m, 5000m and 10,000m. She continued to compete following her collegiate career, qualifying for the U.S. Olympic Trials in 1984 and 1988. She was inducted into the UW-La Crosse Athletics Hall of Fame in 1994, and now has a meet named in her honor at the school.