Stenhouse was a sprint-jump legend in Division III, capturing eight NCAA titles and 23 USTFCCCA All-America honors. She won four national crowns in the triple jump, three coming outdoors in 1989, 1990, and 1991. At the 1991 outdoor championships at Baldwin-Wallace, Stenhouse won national crowns in the 200m, 400m, and triple jump and was a Honda Award nominee that year for her efforts. Stenhouse holds the ECAC Division III triple jump record (40-5½, 12.33m). Stenhouse, originally from Jamaica Estates, N.Y., earned an NCAA Post-Graduate Scholarship and competed at the USATF Championships after college.