From 2003 to 2006, Jarocki won 10 NCAA titles across four throwing events with four coming in the shot put, three in the weight throw, two in the discus throw and one in the hammer throw. Jarocki still holds the NCAA Division III record in the outdoor shot put with a heave of 16.77m (55-0¼), sits fifth on the chart for the discus throw (52.34m/171-8) and is the ninth best performer in NCAA DIII history in the hammer throw (58.80m/192-11). She starred at the NCAA championships and owns indoor championship records in the shot put and weight throw and the outdoor championship record in the shot put.
UW-Oshkosh flourished while Jarocki was on campus, winning five national titles including indoor and outdoor titles in 2004 and 2006. The Titans also won the indoor title in 2005.