Kibler, a sophomore from Warrenville, Illinois, was named National Women’s Track Athlete of the Year. She had her hand in four event titles at the 2021 NJCAA Division III Outdoor Track & Field Championships, winning the 400 and 800 as an individual and running a leg of the first-place 4×400 and 4×800 relay teams. Kibler also finished fourth in the 5000. During the regular season, Kibler topped the Descending Order List in both the 400 and 800.